In Their Own Words

  • Ellen Scheinberg

Abstract

The author reviews three books written during the 1990s which rely on oral history to explore the lives of Japanese picture brides, refugees, and female Native elders. This article reveals how these three works succeed in using oral history to give voice to the individuals from these non-hegemonic groups that had been neglected by scholars in the past. It also explores some of the pitfalls that can arise when adoptingan oral history method that fails to recognize the role of the interviewer as well as incorporate any authorial interpretation into the work. The article calls for more transparency and greater balance when producing oral histories.

RÉSUMÉ

L’auteure commente trois ouvrages des années 1990 basés sur l’histoireorale et destinés à explorer la vie de Japonaises mariées par correspondance, deréfugiés et de vieilles autochtones. L’article montre comment ces trois livres ont réussià utiliser l’histoire orale pour donner la parole à des personnes faisant partie de groupes non dominants et qui ont été négligés par les chercheurs dans le passé. Il explore également quelques-uns des pièges dans lesquels on peut tomber en adoptant une méthode d’histoire orale qui ne reconnaît pas le rôle de l’interviewer et qui n’intègre pas d’interprétation solide dans le travail. Dès lors, ce texte appelle à une plus grande transparence et à un plus grand équilibre lors de la production d’histoires orales.

Author Biography

Ellen Scheinberg
For ten years, Ellen Scheinberg was an archivist with the former Government Archives and Records Disposition Division at the National Archives of Canada, until May 2000 when she moved to the University of Toronto Archives. She holds an M.A. in history from Queen’s University and is currently working on a Ph.D. in history at the University of Ottawa. She has written several archival and historical articles on female textile workers, domestic servants, and case files. Her current research relates to her dissertation topic of immigrant women and Canadian deportation policy.
Published
2000-02-18
How to Cite
Scheinberg, Ellen. 2000. “In Their Own Words”. Archivaria 49 (February), 204-13. https://archivaria.ca/index.php/archivaria/article/view/12745.
Section
Review Articles