An Accidental Archive of the Old Durham Road: Reclaiming a Black Pioneer Settlement

  • Naomi Norquay

Abstract

This article considers how the land might be utilized as an archive of a “disappeared” historic community of black settlers in Grey County, Ontario. The paucity of resources about this community (beyond the censuses that marked race as a category), as well as past and current efforts to deny its existence, are considered. Drawing on Jonathan Silin’s notion of teacher as “accidental archivist,”[1] the article explores how the land along the Old Durham Road, where these settlers lived, might be considered an “accidental archive.” Three “evidences” of the settlement are taken up: wild apple trees, a stone foundation, and crockery shards from a kitchen midden. Through seasonal changes, the land both hides and reveals, suggesting both the literal and the metaphoric “absent presence” of this historic community. In closing, the article explores how this archive might best be accessed.

 

RÉSUMÉ

Cet article se penche sur la manière dont des terres pourraient servir d’archives à une communauté historique « disparue » de colons noirs du comté de Grey, en Ontario. L’article considère la pénurie de ressources au sujet de cette communauté (au-delà des recensements qui notaient la race comme catégorie), ainsi que les efforts passés et présents pour nier son existence. En s’inspirant de la pensée de Jonathan Silin au sujet de l’enseignant comme « archiviste accidentel »,1 cet article explore comment les terres le long du chemin Old Durham, où ces colons ont vécu, pourraient être considérées comme des « archives accidentelles ».[1] Trois « preuves » de l’établissement sont examinées : des pommiers sauvages, une fondation de pierre et des tessons de faïence provenant d’un tas d’ordures de cuisine. Avec le changement des saisons, les terres cachent et révèlent, suggérant à la fois la « présence absente » littérale et métaphorique de cette communauté historique. En terminant, cet article examine la meilleure façon d’avoir accès à ces archives.

[1] Jonathan Silin, “The Teacher as Accidental Archivist,” Studies in Gender and Sexuality 15, no. 2 (April 2014): 133–42.

Author Biography

Naomi Norquay

Naomi Norquay is an associate professor in the Faculty of Education at York University, Toronto. With a background in curriculum theory and life history research, she is interested in challenging the discourse of “the white pioneer” as it is presented in school curricula. Her current research explores the historic Old Durham Road black pioneer settlement in Grey County. This research includes the archives, an oral history project, and a partnership with teachers and students in a local school. She is interested in arts-informed interpretations of this previously silenced and denied historic community. As a property owner along the road, she is also a member of the Old Durham Road Pioneer Cemetery Committee, currently serving as the group’s president.

Published
2016-04-28
How to Cite
Norquay, Naomi. 2016. “An Accidental Archive of the Old Durham Road: Reclaiming a Black Pioneer Settlement”. Archivaria 81 (April), 1-22. https://archivaria.ca/index.php/archivaria/article/view/13555.
Section
Articles