Sampling Methodology and its Application: An Illustration of the Tension Between Theory and Practice?

  • Evelyn Kolish

Abstract

In the context of a conference on archivists caught between "the rock and a hard place," sampling offers several ways of illustrating the compromises that inevitably take place in the dialectic between theory and practice. This article examines briefly two of the ways in which sampling confronts us with the tension between theory and practice: first, the choice of sampling as a method of selection, in and of itself; second, the practical problems of applying a specific sampling methodology to the untidy reality of a mass of accumulated documents. Both these reflections are set in the specific context of Quebec's retention decisions with regards to court records and the Archives nationales du Québec's recent experience in applying a particular sampling method to those records.

RÉSUMÉ

Cet article étudie les tensions entre la théorie et la pratique de l'échantillonnage des dossiers de l'arriéré du projet d'échantillonnage des dossiers judiciaires du Québec. L'article examine d'abord les raisons qui ont motivé le choix de l'échantillonnage statistique des dossiers des cours de justice comme instrument de tri tel qu'énoncé dans le Report of the Interministerial Committee on Court Records. Une seconde partie explique la méthode spécifique d'échantillonnage développée par le Comité et se penche sur les diverses difficultés d'application rencontrées durant les deux dernières années: système de classement maison hétérodoxe, classement alphabétique, juridictions partagées, et l'impact des pardons. L'article termine en suggérant, malgré le fait que plusiers problèmes peuvent être résolus sans compromettre la justesse de cette méthode, que quelques obstacles exigent un tel investissement de ressources humaines pour être surmontées, que l'échantillonnage ne représente plus une solution rentable. Les archivistes et les gestionnaires devront faire la part des choses entre les exigences de la représentivité et la précision et leurs coûts en ressources humaines et matérielles.

Author Biography

Evelyn Kolish
Born in Toronto, Evelyn Kolish received her B.A. in history from the University of Toronto in 1972, her M.A. in history from Queen Mary College, at the University of London in 1974, and her Ph.D. in history from the UniversitC de MontrCal in 1980. In 1986-87, she also completed the first year of the MLIS at McGill University. A specialist in the legal history of Lower Canada, Dr. Kolish taught Quebec and Canadian history at Concordia University and the UniversitC du QuCbec a MontrCal for some years before becoming the archivist in charge of court records at the Montreal centre of the Archives nationales du QuCbec in 1990. Since then, she has been principally occupied in the planning and implementation of the recommendations of Quebec's Interministerial Committee on Court Records.
Published
1994-02-07
How to Cite
Kolish, Evelyn. 1994. “Sampling Methodology and Its Application: An Illustration of the Tension Between Theory and Practice?”. Archivaria 38 (February), 61-73. https://archivaria.ca/index.php/archivaria/article/view/12024.
Section
Articles